Home  |  Contact Us  |  @GiantsBlogger Twitter  |  Giants Blog Instagram  |  GBB Facebook 

Thursday, September 18, 2008


With the season winding down, and not much new going on with the Giants (Matt Cain is still getting no run-support and the team looks like it's just playing out the schedule, sans Tim Lincecum), I am going to go ahead and pick who I think should win the major awards in each league. Yes, there is still 2 weeks left and a lot can change, but if the season were to end today, here's my pics:


NL MVP: Ryan Howard, PHI: The .249 batting average aside, he has been the best player in baseball this year. It's amazing what he's done after such a slow start, and he is the main reason the Phillies are ahead in a tough NL East. Albert Pujols is a close second, but he hasn't carried the Cards' like Howard has Philly. Honorable Mention: Pujols, Stl.; Lance Berkman, Hou.; David Wright, NYM.

Tim Lincecum, SF: Call me biased, but there has not been a pitcher better or more dominant in 2008 than Tim Lincecum. Yes, Brandon Webb has the 20 wins, but put Timmy in Arizona and he'd have darn near 25. C.C. Sabathia has been great, but he's only been in the league for 2 months. Lincecum leads the league in era and strikeouts and may even make it to 20 wins with a team that should only win 72. No knock on Brandon Webb or even Sabathia, but you ask any ML hitter right now who they'd rather face, and nobody would say Lincecum. Honorable mention: Webb, AZ; Johan Santana, NYM.

Charlie Manuel, PHI: He's had the Phills at or near the top of a very tough division all year long. Whether it's as a wild card, or the NL East winners, they will be in the playoffs and IMO, they'll be the team to beat in the NL. Honorable Mention: Freddi Gonzalez, Fla.

Geovany Soto, CHI: Soto's 22 home runs and 83 RBI topped all NL Rookies in 2008. He also sported a solid batting average all-season long and has been nails behind the plate for the Cubs. He's a big reason why the Cubs lead the NL Central by 9 games, not the other, more headline worthy rookie on this team (Kosuke Fukudome). Honorable Mention: Jair Jurgens, Atl.

Jorge Cantu, Fla.: It's tough to imagine that this guy had trouble finding a job this spring. A lot of teams are kicking themselves for turning down his services, including the Giants who could have desperately used him. All he's done after barely squeezing onto the Marlins OD roster: .274, 27, 86, which would be about 26 home runs and 72 RBI better than last years effort. Honorable mention: Fernando Tatis, NYM.


AL MVP: Josh Hamilton, Tex.: I'm usually one that likes to take the MVP's off of winning ball-clubs, but Hamilton has been special this year. He did slow down in the second half, but him, Milton Bradley and Ian Kinsler have single handily turned Texas into a competitive ball club. Like the NL though, there isn't a clear cut winner and there are 3 or 4 guys that deserve it just the same. I take Hamilton just because I think he's been the best player, from start to finish, in the AL this year. Honorable Mention: Alex Rodriguez, NYY; Carlos Quentin, ChW; Dustin Pedroia, Bos.

Cliff Lee, Cle.: Just when you think the veteran lefty will come back to earth, he puts together another amazing start. Minus the strikeouts, he's done to the AL hitters what Tim Lincecum has done in NL. He leads the league in wins and era and even though his team isn't going to the playoffs, Lee should run away with this award. Honorable Mention: Roy Halladay, Tor; Daisuke Matsuzaka, Bos.; Francisco Rodriguez, LAA.

Joe Maddon, Tam.: This is really the easiest pick of all end of season awards in 2008. Joe Maddon had the Rays atop the division all year long and even if they somehow miss the playoffs, which is highly unlikely, this guy has done a helluva job with a team most picked to finish no higher than 3rd or 4th in the division. Not only will he win this award with ease, but he will also entrench himself into the baseball managerial elite. Honorable Mention: Ozzie Guillen, ChW; Mike Sciosia, LAA.

AL ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Evan Longoria, Tam.: Another Ray destined for hardware after the season, Longoria could have been in the MVP talks had he started the year with the team instead of AAA. In less than 400 at-bats, Longoria has 22 bombs and 74 RBI to go along with a .278 average. If it weren't for him, Tampa Bay isn't in first place. Honorable Mention: Chris Davis, Tex.; Alexi Ramirez, ChW.

Edwin Jackson, Tam.: The Rays are number 1 in the best division in the game for a reason, and that's been their starting pitching. Jackson's put together his best year as a major leaguer after years and years of disappointment in LA and Tampa. 11 wins and a 4.33 era aren't earth shattering numbers, but he now only has 22 wins in 113 big league games, so half of them have come in the last 5 months. Not quite living up to expectations fully yet, but the 25 year old looks like he's finally molding into that top of the rotation pitcher everyone thought he'd be. Honorable Mention: Eric Hinske, Tam.; Octavio Dotel, ChW.
The Giants Baseball Blog


  • At 11:28 PM, Anonymous Manny Stiles said…

    I agree with you on Lincecum, but "put Timmy in Arizona and he'd have darn near 25 (wins)."???? Do you really have THAT high of respect for a sub-.500 team???

    It's closer than you think between Lincecum and Webb... 20+ wins on the D-Backs is more impressive than you realize!

  • At 2:17 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Lincecum all the way, but I'd take Wright for MVP in NL.

  • At 4:04 PM, Anonymous APOSTROPHE said…

    Chicago is four games from clinching the division and seven games better than any other team in the National League. How do you not give Sweet Lou the Coach of the Year Award?

  • At 8:31 PM, Anonymous Romiezzo said…

    I agree with you on Lincecum, but "there has not been a pitcher better or more dominant in 2008 than Tim Lincecum, NL or AL. I don't know dude. I'd say that Cliff Lee's up there too...

  • At 11:29 PM, Anonymous JuTMSY4 said…

    if the mets make the playoffs would it be wrong to give it to jerry manuel?

  • At 1:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Yeah, but the mets are stacked, they should be in the playoffs regardless.

  • At 11:17 AM, Anonymous The oldest man said…

    The oldest man
    I agree with some but no Mike S of the Angels. 161/2 games up in early Sept and already the pennant in Western Division of American League. Give the guy a break, they were picked as one of the favorites but since the all-star break they have played the best ball in the majors.

  • At 7:24 PM, Anonymous Romiezzo said…

    I understand why you're picking Mike Scioscia. However, I think I can elaborate on Trecole's opinion about Joe Maddon.

    Let's take a look back at where the Rays stood before the 2008 Spring Training. Many thought they were going to be 4th place (at most third). Joe Maddon, however, has made some great decisions and have won several close games based on Maddon's decisions.
    Mike Scioscia has always been a great coach, but these Rays are just too good of a Cinderella story for Maddon not to win the Manager of the Year award. I'll say Scioscia is a close second.

  • At 4:18 PM, Anonymous Kelsdad said…

    Anyone else find it interesting the top only two candidates for NL Cy Young are both on losing teams?

  • At 7:55 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    im shocked at the manager of the year for the NL and the AL mvp


Post a Comment

<< Home